Workplace Harassment Lawyer: Withstanding Workplace Injustices

Shield Your Civil liberties: When to Talk to an Employment Legal Representative



In today's facility job landscape, understanding your civil liberties as a worker is crucial. Recognizing when to look for legal counsel from a work attorney can indicate the difference in between guarding your passions or dealing with prospective lawful pitfalls. From navigating discrimination concerns to solving disputes over unpaid earnings, the experience of an employment legal representative can give very useful advice. Stay informed and equipped in your workplace by identifying the signs that might necessitate the advise of an attorney.




Wrongful Dismissal LawyerWorkplace Discrimination Lawyer

Signs of Discrimination at the office



In the office, acknowledging indicators of discrimination can be essential for preserving a reasonable and inclusive atmosphere for all staff members. Discrimination can manifest in different kinds, including however not restricted to unequal therapy, harassment, or exclusion based on secured features such as race, gender, age, religion, or special needs. Among one of the most common indications of discrimination is when people undergo differential treatment compared to their peers in similar functions. This can be seen in variations in promos, pay, or opportunities for development based on non-performance associated aspects.


In addition, inequitable habits may also appear in the form of bad comments, offensive jokes, or exclusionary practices that create an aggressive job atmosphere for specific individuals. It is important for employers and staff members alike to be cautious and aggressive in determining and attending to these indications of discrimination immediately to support a culture of respect, equal rights, and diversity in the office. By staying notified and responsive to such indications, organizations can promote a more unified and supportive workplace for everybody.




Understanding Wrongful Discontinuation Legislations



 


Comprehending the legal implications of wrongful discontinuation is critical for both employers and employees in navigating the complexities of employment law. Wrongful termination happens when a worker is terminated for reasons that breach government or state anti-discrimination legislations, violation of contract, or retaliation for exercising their legal rights. It is vital for companies to be conscious of the legislations surrounding termination to prevent expensive litigation and damage to their track record. Workers, on the other hand, need to understand their rights and options if they think they have actually been wrongfully ended.




Severance Pay LawyerEmployment Lawyer Toronto
Employment laws differ by territory, yet they normally forbid firing employees based on variables such as race, sex, age, special needs, religious beliefs, or sexual orientation. Additionally, staff members can not be ended in retaliation for reporting illegal tasks, submitting a problem, or taking legally protected leave. It is very important for both events to seek legal advice from a knowledgeable work attorney to understand their civil liberties and commitments concerning wrongful termination. By being notified and proactive, companies and workers can safeguard themselves and make certain reasonable treatment in the office.




Dealing With Unpaid Wage Conflicts



Browsing the intricate landscape of employment regulation, especially in situations of wrongful discontinuation, can often lead to disputes over unsettled wages that need resolution. Overdue wage disputes can develop for numerous reasons, such as employers falling short to spend for overtime work, keeping last paychecks, or not making up for all hours functioned. When encountered with such disputes, it is vital to take prompt action to secure your civil liberties.




 


Handling overdue wage disagreements frequently includes understanding pertinent labor regulations, employment contracts, and business plans. An experienced employment attorney can assist you browse with these intricacies, analyze the toughness of your instance, and determine the very best course of action. They can aid in bargaining with your employer, filing an official problem with the labor division, and even representing you in court if required.




Navigating Workplace Harassment Claims





When dealing with workplace harassment cases, it is important to approach each instance with thoroughness and level of sensitivity. Workplace harassment can take numerous types, consisting of however not limited to spoken, physical, or unwanted sexual advances, developing a hostile workplace. Staff members who experience harassment might feel intimidated, distressed, and even are afraid retaliation, making it critical for employers to take these cases seriously.


Navigating office harassment declares calls for a tactical and understanding technique. Companies should have clear plans and procedures in position for reporting and dealing with harassment claims. It is vital to conduct timely and neutral investigations to figure out the validity of the insurance claims and take ideal actions to fix the scenario.


Employees dealing with harassment needs to document events, maintain documents of any type of interaction, and look for support from HR or a work legal representative if needed. A knowledgeable work lawyer can provide support on lawful alternatives, support in filing grievances with appropriate authorities, and stand for staff members in negotiations or legal procedures to guarantee their rights are protected. By dealing with work environment harassment asserts promptly and efficiently, business can promote a secure and considerate workplace for all staff members.




Looking For Lawful Advice for Agreement Disputes



Upon coming across agreement disagreements in the office, looking for lawful guidance is essential for this hyperlink settling problems effectively and safeguarding your rate of interests. Agreement conflicts can emerge from various issues such as breach of contract, misconception of terms, or differences over commitments. When encountered with such obstacles, talking to a work lawyer can Going Here offer important insights right into your civil liberties and alternatives for attending to the conflict.




Severance Pay LawyerSeverance Pay Lawyer
An employment lawyer can review the agreement in inquiry, analyze the conditions bordering the conflict, and offer assistance on the best training course of activity to take - wrongful dismissal Toronto. They can assist you comprehend your legal civil liberties, responsibilities, and prospective remedies readily available to solve the dispute. Furthermore, an experienced legal representative can represent your rate of interests in negotiations, mediation, or litigation if essential




 



Final Thought



In conclusion, seeking advice from with an employment legal representative is necessary in protecting your civil liberties in various office situations such as discrimination, wrongful discontinuation, unpaid wage disagreements, workplace harassment insurance claims, and contract conflicts. By looking for legal support, individuals can navigate intricate employment regulations and patent attorney near me ensure they are dealt with fairly in the work environment. It is necessary to be notified of your civil liberties and options when confronted with legal problems at the office.

 

Examine This Report on Interpreters & Trial Presentations

Enhance Your Lawful Procedures With Specialist Interpreters and Trial Presentations



In the elaborate landscape of legal proceedings, the use of specialist interpreters and trial discussions can work as vital tools in making certain quality, precision, and convincing interaction within the court room - INTERPRETERS & TRIAL PRESENTATIONS. Whether seeking or navigating a multilingual setting to reinforce the influence of crucial evidentiary product, the experience of interpreters and the tactical release of trial presentations can significantly strengthen the presentation of a case. As attorneys strive to create compelling narratives and existing compelling disagreements, the integration of these specialist services can lead the way for a more engaging and reliable legal technique




Relevance of Expert Interpreters



The use of knowledgeable professional interpreters is critical in making certain exact interaction and understanding in lawful proceedings. In the realm of legislation, where accuracy and quality are non-negotiable, the role of interpreters ends up being vital. Expert interpreters possess not just linguistic fluency however additionally a deep understanding of lawful terminology and nuances, allowing them to communicate information accurately without any type of false impression. Their capability to promote effective communication between events that talk different languages aids keep the stability of the lawful procedure, making certain that all people entailed understand the procedures fully.




 


In addition, professional interpreters maintain stringent codes of principles and discretion, assuring that delicate info shared during lawful interactions continues to be safe and protected. By bridging language voids, interpreters enable smooth interactions in between lawyers, judges, witnesses, and customers, fostering a setting of openness and fairness within the lawful system. Ultimately, their experience decreases the risk of miscommunication or misconception, safeguarding the legal rights and passions of all events associated with lawful process.




INTERPRETERS & TRIAL PRESENTATIONSINTERPRETERS & TRIAL PRESENTATIONS

Benefits of Test Presentations



Utilizing trial presentations improves the efficacy of lawful disagreements and help in the comprehension of complex proof - INTERPRETERS & TRIAL PRESENTATIONS. By including aesthetic help, such as graphes, computer animations, timelines, and graphs, trial presentations aid legal experts existing details in a more interesting and absorbable way. These visual tools can simplify elaborate details, making it easier for judges, jurors, and various other stakeholders to understand the bottom lines of an instance




INTERPRETERS & TRIAL PRESENTATIONSINTERPRETERS & TRIAL PRESENTATIONS
Moreover, test presentations can improve the persuasiveness of arguments by providing a well organized and clear structure to the presentation of evidence. Offering details in an aesthetically attractive format can aid to emphasize critical realities and reinforce the general story of the case. Furthermore, using innovation in trial presentations can make the courtroom proceedings more effective and structured, conserving time and ensuring that the emphasis continues to be on the material of the lawful arguments.




Enhancing Witness Testimonies



Enhancing witness testaments through critical visual aids can considerably reinforce the efficiency of lawful disagreements in court procedures. By including aesthetic elements such as representations, timelines, or interactive important site discussions, attorneys can assist jurors better recognize complex info and preserve vital details from witness testimonies.


Aesthetic help act as effective tools to improve the trustworthiness and quality of witness testaments. Demonstrative exhibitions can simplify complex principles, making them a lot more obtainable to a diverse target market. Furthermore, aesthetic aids can enhance the consistency and coherence of witness statements, assisting to develop an engaging story that sustains the legal debate being provided.


Furthermore, utilizing innovation to existing witness testaments can involve jurors more successfully, keeping them conscientious and focused throughout the process. Interactive discussions can enhance juror retention prices and aid in their decision-making process by giving a visual recommendation that complements the spoken testament offered.




Visual Aids in the Court Room



Incorporating aesthetic help in the courtroom setup can successfully strengthen the presentation of witness testaments and boost the persuasiveness of lawful debates. Aesthetic help such as charts, charts, pictures, video clips, and 3D computer animations can assist streamline complex information, making it a lot more obtainable and compelling for jurors and judges. By giving aesthetic representations of proof or bottom lines, lawyers can enhance the clarity and impact of their disagreements, bring about a better understanding and retention of crucial details throughout the test.


In addition, aesthetic help can function as a powerful device for enhancing the trustworthiness of witness statements. For instance, displaying maps or timelines can help witnesses show their narratives more cohesively, boosting the possibility of their statements being perceived as honest and reputable. Furthermore, aesthetic read the full info here help can assist in capturing the attention of the audience, maintaining involvement throughout the procedures, and leaving a long lasting impression that sustains the lawful team's case concept. Therefore, utilizing visual help in the court room can substantially add to the efficiency and success of lawful discussions.




Methods for Lawful Success



Executing tactical methods is essential for attaining legal success in the courtroom. One crucial strategy is detailed situation preparation. Lawyers need to meticulously review all evidence, laws, and precedents relevant to the situation. This prep work guarantees that they can expect disagreements from the opposite counsel and properly counter them. An additional crucial technique works communication. Clear and succinct communication with customers, witnesses, and jurors is critical. Lawyers should share intricate lawful principles in a manner that is easily understood by all events involved. In addition, building a strong instance story is necessary. Crafting a compelling story that resonates with the discretionary can considerably affect wikipedia reference the result of a situation. Remaining versatile throughout legal proceedings is important. Lawyers have to be prepared to pivot their techniques based upon the judge's judgments, witness testimonies, and various other unforeseen developments. By applying these calculated approaches, attorneys can enhance their opportunities of success in the court room.




Final Thought



In final thought, professional interpreters and trial presentations play a vital duty in improving legal proceedings. By guaranteeing exact communication and providing information successfully, they can dramatically influence the end result of a situation. Making use of these resources can help enhance witness statements, give visual aids for quality, and eventually add to an effective lawful strategy. It is essential for lawyers to recognize the worth of these devices in accomplishing positive cause court.




As lawful professionals aim to build engaging stories and existing compelling arguments, the combination of these specialist services can pave the means for an extra efficient and engaging lawful approach.


By incorporating visual aids, such as charts, timelines, computer animations, and charts, trial presentations help legal professionals present info in an extra engaging and absorbable manner.Incorporating aesthetic aids in the court room setup can effectively strengthen the presentation of witness statements and bolster the persuasiveness of legal disagreements. By offering aesthetic representations of proof or crucial points, legal specialists can boost the clearness and impact of their debates, leading to a far better understanding and retention of crucial information during the test.


Furthermore, visual help can aid in recording the interest of the target market, preserving engagement throughout the process, and leaving a long lasting impact that supports the lawful group's case concept.

 

What Does Laurens Sc Motorcycle Accident Lawyer Do?

The 20-Second Trick For Laurens Sc Motorcycle Accident Lawyer


If you have actually lately remained in a motorcycle accident in California, you might be wondering whether or not you require to work with a lawyer to handle your situation. While it's feasible to browse the lawful system on your own, dealing with an experienced attorney can dramatically improve your chances of receiving a fair settlement.


The amount of compensation you may be qualified to will rely on the degree of your injuries and the economic losses you have actually incurred. An attorney can assist you determine your damages and make sure that you obtain a fair negotiation. Insurer are often much more concerned with securing their profits than they are with supplying reasonable settlement to mishap targets.


While it's possible to deal with a motorbike crash case by yourself, there are several scenarios where it's highly suggested to seek legal depiction. These consist of: If you've endured serious injuries in a bike mishap, dealing with a lawyer is vital. They can assist you navigate the complex lawful system and make certain that you obtain the payment you need to cover your medical expenditures and shed earnings.


When selecting an attorney, look for somebody who has experience handling motorcycle crash situations and who has a record of success (Laurens SC Motorcycle Accident Lawyer). Furthermore, ensure they are communicative, receptive, and very easy to deal with. The length of time it takes to solve an instance will depend upon a range of aspects, including the complexity of the case, the level of your injuries, and whether or not obligation is clear




Some Known Details About Laurens Sc Motorcycle Accident Lawyer




Even though I had not been involved in the crash, Evan made every effort to make the process of obtaining my new automobile pain-free for me. This obscures the lines of liability, as lots of vehicle drivers will wrongly declare a bike was weaving in and out of web traffic when actually it was the car that swerved. Since of the active nature of motorbikes, their movements occur quickly so mishaps can occur also quicker.


You should have to have your virtue safeguarded. A legal representative will certainly aid build your case. When you recall the details of your motorbike crash situation to a legal representative, they grab the items and aid put together a strong disagreement for safeguarding your innocence and establishing fault. It can be difficult to safeguard on important source your own without one, as just a personal injury attorney knows the subtleties of motorbike accident law.


If you are unsure whether you need a legal representative, it's ideal to get in touch with one. The Leddy Law Practice, LLC offers a complimentary no-obligation assessment ** to any individual thinking about employing legal advice in relation to a motorbike mishap. For those who have suffered medical conditions and physical injuries after a motorcycle accident, it's important to speak with an attorney who can combat to recuperate any expenses with which you've been strained.




A Biased View of Laurens Sc Motorcycle Accident Lawyer


For those who miss job due to motorcycle crash injuries, shed wages should be accounted for in your awarded settlement. Frequently these processes are too hard to browse alone, and if you miss a vital part of the lawsuits process, you may fall short to get money that's justly owed to you.




 


Every day, numerous motorcyclists obtain right into accidents due to the negligence of other motorists. Those entailed in a crash while riding their bike must comprehend what legal steps to take following the occurrence.




Laurens SC Motorcycle Accident LawyerLaurens SC Motorcycle Accident Lawyer
During a preliminary appointment, lawyers commonly review authorities reports, witness declarations, pictures taken at the scene, and any kind of other proof relevant to the instance. They also speak to their customer regarding their experience and exactly how it has impacted their life because then. This assists them understand what occurred previously, throughout, and after the accident, allowing them to craft strong lawful debates that stand up in court if required.


When this happens, the faulty chauffeur needs to be held answerable for carelessness and carelessness so that justice can prevail. A seasoned bike accident attorney in Jacksonville is accountable for accumulating evidence to find more show that the try this out at-fault party was responsible for the accident. The variation of occasions informed by the motorbike cyclist will offer details regarding where they were going, what they saw prior to the crash, and just how it took place.




The Buzz on Laurens Sc Motorcycle Accident Lawyer


Laurens SC Motorcycle Accident LawyerLaurens SC Motorcycle Accident Lawyer
With all this in mind, it is time to identify the value of a motorcycle crash situation in Jacksonville, FL. Numerous variables need to be thought about when establishing the value of a motorbike mishap case in Jacksonville, FL. A competent motorbike crash attorney is vital for accurately examining all aspects of an injury claim and identifying its overall worth.


With an experienced group on your side striving every step of the way, you have a much higher opportunity of achieving success with your automobile accident claim. Checking out typical reasons for motorcycle accidents in Jacksonville, FL, is vital to bringing justice to those impacted by these unfortunate cases (Laurens SC Motorcycle Accident Lawyer). As the saying goes, prevention is better than cure


An attorney focusing on this location will better comprehend how the legislation applies and what requirements to be done to secure your civil liberties as a hurt person. There is also a time limitation on suing after being injuredknown as the statute of limitationswhich varies from one state to another however is typically two years from when the event happened.

 

Family Matters: Comprehensive Legal Support from a Dedicated Family Lawyer

Top Tips for Locating the most effective Immigration Lawyer Near You



When it pertains to navigating the intricacies of Immigration legislation, locating the ideal lawyer can make a substantial difference in the end result of your case. With a multitude of lawyers using their solutions, the task of picking the very best Immigration legal representative near you can be intimidating.


Understanding the crucial factors that differentiate a skilled lawyer from the rest is important. From assessing on the internet testimonials to seeking suggestions, there are essential steps that can lead you towards making a notified choice.


By following these top pointers, you can ensure that you have the support of a knowledgeable Immigration attorney that will certainly promote your legal requirements successfully.




Immigration AttorneyFamily Attorney

 



Research Online Reviews



When looking for the most effective Immigration legal representative near you, it is important to carefully research online testimonials to analyze their online reputation and performance history. On-line evaluations offer important insights right into the experiences of previous clients with a particular lawyer or law company. By examining these evaluations, you can acquire a better understanding of the legal representative's toughness, weak points, and overall proficiency in handling Immigration situations.


When looking into on the internet evaluations, pay interest to persisting patterns or themes. Romanian Immigration Attorney. Seek feedback on the lawyer's interaction skills, responsiveness, understanding of Immigration regulation, success price, and overall professionalism. Favorable reviews highlighting pleased customers and successful end results can instill self-confidence in your decision to employ a specific attorney




 


In comparison, unfavorable testimonials that consistently point out issues like lack of interaction, unresponsiveness, or incompetence ought to elevate red flags. Remember that while some unfavorable testimonials might be outliers, a pattern of discontented customers is a reason for issue. Inevitably, comprehensive research study of on-line testimonials is an essential step in discovering the ideal Immigration legal representative to represent your case effectively.




Look For Recommendations From Household & Buddies



Think about seeking referrals from friends and family who might have had favorable experiences with Immigration attorneys in your area. Personal recommendations can give beneficial understandings into the lawyer's interaction design, know-how, and general effectiveness in handling Immigration instances - Asylum Lawyer NY. By reaching out to your trusted circle, you might discover hidden treasures or avoid potential risks when choosing an Immigration legal representative


Friends and family can offer direct accounts of their interactions with a certain attorney, shedding light on vital aspects such as transparency, success, and responsiveness price. They can likewise direct you on what to anticipate throughout the lawful process and just how the attorney navigated obstacles comparable to your very own.


Furthermore, recommendations from loved ones feature a level of depend on and integrity that online evaluations or promotions may lack. Recognizing that someone you understand and trust fund had a positive experience with an Immigration attorney can infuse confidence as you make your decision. Do not ignore the power of looking for references from family members and buddies when looking for the best Immigration lawyer near you.




Inspect Qualifications and Experience



Having actually collected references from friends and family, the following essential have a peek at this website step in discovering the very best Immigration legal representative near you is to extensively examine the qualifications and experience of possible prospects. When assessing a lawyer's credentials, look for memberships in reliable Immigration law qualifications, licenses, and organizations to practice regulation in your territory. These qualifications suggest a lawyer's commitment to remaining educated regarding Immigration laws and regulations.


Experience is another critical variable to take into consideration. Inquire regarding the attorney's experience handling cases comparable to your own and ask about their success rate. A seasoned Immigration attorney is more probable to prepare for obstacles, supply tactical advice, and browse the intricacies of your case effectively. In addition, think about the lawyer's knowledge with the Immigration court system and their connections with Immigration officers, which can greatly affect the outcome of your instance.




Schedule Examinations With Multiple Attorneys



To make an educated decision when selecting the ideal Immigration attorney near you, it is suggested to schedule examinations with numerous lawyers. By consulting with various Immigration lawyers, you can gain important understandings right into their interaction style, level of experience, and overall compatibility with your needs. During these examinations, be prepared to ask pertinent questions about the attorney's experience in managing instances comparable to your own, their success price, and the strategies they propose for your particular circumstance.




Immigration LawyerRussian Immigration Lawyer
Consulting with numerous lawyers likewise enables you to compare cost frameworks and layaway plan, making certain that you locate an attorney who offers fair and clear prices. Additionally, these appointments provide you the opportunity to analyze the legal representative's willingness, expertise, and responsiveness to address your concerns.


Eventually, organizing assessments with numerous Immigration attorneys encourages you to make a well-informed choice based upon firsthand communications, helping you choose the most effective legal depiction for your Immigration requires. Immigration Attorney.




Evaluate Communication and Convenience Degree



When reviewing an Immigration lawyer's suitability for your particular lawful demands,Analyzing the effectiveness of communication and establishing a sense of comfort are essential variables. Open and clear communication is important for guaranteeing that you and your attorney get on the very same web page throughout the Immigration procedure. A skilled Immigration attorney must have the ability to describe intricate legal principles in such a way that you can understand, keeping you notified and associated with decision-making.




 


During your first examinations, focus on just how well the attorney pays attention to your worries and questions. An excellent Immigration attorney will certainly make an effort to recognize your private circumstances and attend to any unpredictabilities you might have. Furthermore, analyze whether you feel Get the facts comfy talking about individual and delicate info with the legal representative, as count on and hop over to here discretion are important in lawful matters.


Eventually, locating an Immigration lawyer with whom you have great interaction and a comfortable connection can dramatically impact the success of your situation. Trust fund your instincts and select a legal representative that not only has the needed expertise yet also makes you feel at convenience throughout the lawful process.




Conclusion



In final thought, locating the ideal Immigration lawyer near you requires detailed research. Seek referrals and inspect credentials and experience. Arrange appointments with numerous lawyers and assess communication and comfort levels.


By complying with these ideas, people can guarantee they discover a certified and credible attorney to help them with their Immigration requires.




Immigration AttorneySpanish Immigration Attorney
When seeking the best Immigration legal representative near you, it is necessary to very carefully investigate online testimonials to examine their credibility and track document. Eventually, extensive research of on-line evaluations is an essential action in discovering the best Immigration legal representative to represent your situation effectively.


Having actually gathered references from family and close friends, the next crucial action in discovering the best Immigration attorney near you is to thoroughly examine the credentials and experience of possible candidates. Furthermore, consider the legal representative's experience with the Immigration court system and their partnerships with Immigration policemans, which can substantially influence the outcome of your situation.


To make an informed decision when picking the best Immigration attorney near you, it is suggested to schedule examinations with multiple attorneys.

 

About tenant lawyer

Shut icon Two crossed traces that type an 'X'. It indicates a method to close an conversation, or dismiss a notification.

Every day Business Evaluate honors attorneys and judges who definitely have created a impressive big difference within the legal career in Florida.

In case you are able to get the primary step in safeguarding your legal rights, contact our workforce at LawFirm.com. A circumstance supervisor will talk to you some questions about your accident and set you in contact with a leading automobile accident lawyer in case you meet up with selected standards.

Naturally, If your insurance provider refuses to offer you the money you are worthy of, your vehicle accident lawyer can experience off in opposition to the business’s attorneys in court. But however, it usually takes decades to get a vehicle accident lawsuit for making its way to a courtroom.

It is possible to speak with an auto accident lawyer about how extensive it is possible to anticipate to wait for your settlement revenue.

Anna Summersett is a highly trained criminal trial attorney who may have personally taken care of over 100 jury trials ranging from misdemeanor DWIs to Funds Murder.

Call our workforce at LawFirm.com for any absolutely free circumstance evaluate. Considered one of our situation professionals can set you in contact that has a prime auto accident lawyer should you qualify.

Rob Andretz is passionate about assisting his customers. Rob has had the honor and privilege of becoming licensed to exercise about his law considering that 2003, and He's content To place his education and knowledge while in the fields of regulation, biology, and psychology to work for health professionals in need of his assistance.

If you compromise, site link you receive a settlement through the healthcare employee’s malpractice insurance company in return for providing up your right to sue.

Time is even shorter If you're suing a authorities company for any dangerous roadway issue that caused or contributed to the crash.

No two malpractice claims are the identical, meaning there is absolutely no common or common settlement amount of money. Here are several elements which can ascertain your recovery:

Attorneys reference have an obligation to keep Whatever you say a solution. That’s because of attorney/client privilege. Besides in pretty rare exceptions, In the event your attorney discloses private info you informed them in self confidence, that is a crystal clear illustration of legal malpractice.

Forbes Advisor adheres to rigid editorial integrity benchmarks. For the best of our awareness, all content material is correct as with the day posted, however offers contained herein could no longer be readily available.

You may go after a declare towards the medical professional who harm you as a way to get compensation for malpractice. Often, you can also sue the healthcare facility or clinic that used the health practitioner or care company.

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15